Daryl Dixon Season 2 Reviews Create a Strange Rotten Tomatoes Conundrum

Daryl Dixon returned to screens within the new season of The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon, and reactions from critics on Rotten Tomatoes have been negatively extra constructive this time round. Confused? In an odd twist, the second season of the present, which now has an excellent longer title because of its “The E-book of Carol” prefix, has vastly improved on the 70% Tomatometer rating that Season 1 achieved, but most opinions agree that the brand new season’s opener has not been as robust as its predecessor.

The Strolling Lifeless spin-off sequence debuted its second season on Sunday night time, bravely going up towards Max’s new episode of The Penguin. Whereas the brand new DC sequence has been gaining nearly excellent opinions, Daryl Dixon had one thing to show with its first new episode – which it did by delivering an 89% Tomatometer rating, a large leap in comparison with Season 1. Nevertheless, issues aren’t fairly that easy – like they ever are.

Season 1 of Daryl Dixon aired in 2023, and its “on the day” important opinions weren’t all that constructive, with the sequence gaining an mixture of 61%. This improved over the course of the season, however not by a lot. Compared, based mostly on its first 9 opinions, Season 2 solely has one rotten overview, but most agree that the primary episode is not so good as what got here earlier than it. This consists of Sarah Moran of Screen Rant, who notes that “Daryl Dixon season 2, The E-book of Carol, doesn’t attain the heights of its first…” In the meantime, Collider’s Shawn Van Horn provides that the present “like many episodes of The Strolling Lifeless universe up to now few years, has its ordinary flaws…”

In all circumstances although, these and different opinions have one factor unanimously constructive to say concerning the present’s returning major forged member after her absence from Season 1.

Daryl and Carol are Again Collectively Once more…however is {That a} Good Factor?

The Strolling Lifeless’s Daryl Dixon was at all times meant to function each Norman Reedus’ bike-riding survivor and his companion, Melissa McBride’s Carol. Nevertheless, as a result of circumstances round filming, McBride was unable to decide to filming in Europe and was compelled to tug out of the manufacturing. Though it was clear that she would return if the chance arose, there have been no ensures that Daryl Dixon would get a second season.

Regardless of that, the present was renewed earlier than an episode had even aired, together with the Negan/Maggie spin-off Lifeless Metropolis. With Season 2 a go, McBride’s return was nearly instantly introduced by Carol’s title being added to the season title. This return is one factor that has been unanimously praised by all of the constructive opinions of the present.

“Collectively or aside, Norman Reedus and Melissa McBride are a tour de drive within the exhilarating new season,” says ComicBook’s Cameron Bonomolo. One remark that most likely sums it up completely comes from Radio Occasions’ David Opie, who provides, “It’s undeniably thrilling to see Daryl and Carol again collectively once more, to see this spin-off turn out to be the present it was at all times speculated to be.”

Whereas there have solely been seven viewers opinions to this point, they’re in full disagreement with all of those statements. 5 of the opinions charge the season opener with two stars or much less, and several other make some extent that Carol ought to have been ignored of the sequence solely, as her return “actually spoils what was established, and it’s a repetitive arc once more.” Whether or not the season can flip this round because it progresses is but to be seen, however with Season 3 already filming, it doesn’t appear to be any of those opinions are going to matter by hook or by crook.