Beyoncé’s ‘Cowboy Carter’ shut out of the CMAs. Why some fans are ‘not surprised’

As nominations for this yr’s Nation Music Awards rolled in, one notable title appeared to be lacking from the lineup: Beyoncé.

The Texas native embraced her southern roots earlier this yr with the discharge of “Cowboy Carter,” her first nation album, which has

Nevertheless, the CMAs didn’t depend Beyoncé among the many artists nominated for accolades at this yr’s award ceremony, which is able to happen Nov. 20.

Quite, Luke Combs, Jelly Roll, Chris Stapleton, Morgan Wallen and Lainey Wilson have all been nominated for entertainer of the yr. Quite a few different huge names had been nominated for awards, together with Kacey Musgraves, Kelsea Ballerini, Woman A, Little Massive City, Outdated Dominion, Zac Brown Band, Dan + Shay and Shaboozey, amongst others.

The CMA Awards are voted by members of the Nation Music Affiliation, who’s made up of music executives, artists, publicists, songwriters, musicians, touring personnel and different trade professionals from around the globe, . The nominees and winners are honored by their friends within the music trade, the affiliation shares.

The CMA’s board of administrators are in control of the awards standards, election guidelines and balloting procedures. For the 2024 present, singles, albums, music movies and certified music merchandise should have been first launched or “reached peak nationwide prominence” throughout the eligibility interval of July 1, 2023 by way of June 30, 2024.

Beyoncé’s “Cowboy Carter” was launched March 29, 2024, making it eligible for consideration. Nevertheless, in line with the , every class has its personal guidelines on eligibility. For instance, the only of the yr class notes that the primary spherical of nominees may have a “full checklist of all eligible songs based mostly on charting exercise throughout the eligibility interval.”

TODAY.com has reached out to the Nation Music Affiliation for remark and has not but acquired a response.

After the nominations announcement revealed the Beyoncé shutout, followers, together with Grammy Award winner Kelly Clarkson, shared their ideas in regards to the award present snub.

In an interview with on Sept. 12, Clarkson mentioned she discovered the pop star’s lack of CMA nominations “fascinating.”

“I sort of discover it fascinating as a result of I really feel like these songs had been all over the place,” she mentioned, earlier than she associated the expertise to her personal battle breaking into the nation music scene.

“That’s a tough trade even for me,” she mentioned. “Like, I used to be informed at a lunch, if I didn’t give up pop music and simply go nation, I might not be performed.”

She continued, “I used to be actually informed that to my face at a lunch, and I used to be like, ‘OK, I imply, no offense, however I’m not ever going to only choose one.’”

The daytime discuss present host additionally famous that although it was disappointing to listen to, she wasn’t “shocked” by the information of Bey’s CMA snub.

“I grew up on nation music. I think about Beyoncé did, too. We’re each Texans so you possibly can’t escape it rising up there,” she mentioned. “I believed it will be a extra welcoming setting, but it surely actually wasn’t. That’s why I didn’t pursue it myself as a result of it simply appeared just like the door was closed until I used to be simply all in and needed to go away each different style behind, which I don’t assume folks like me and even Beyoncé are able to doing that.”

Beyoncé has not commented on the shutout. Reps for the artist didn’t instantly reply to TODAY.com’s request for remark.

Learn on to see what others needed to say about Beyoncé not receiving any CMA nominations.

How followers reacted to Beyoncé’s CMA shutout

“As a lot because the CMAs attempt to, the bottom breaking success and affect of Cowboy Carter won’t ever be erased,” one consumer . “Beyoncé broke information, honored nation legends, and paved the best way for brand new black nation artists all whereas releasing a flawless nation album.”

The consumer added, “#They will by no means take that away.”

“Beyoncé INSTEAD soundtracked USA Gymnastics on the Olympics. She ushered in a brand new gen of Black nation artists into the mainstream, together with Shaboozey who has been atop the B100 for 8 wks & counting,” one other consumer . “Solely after having a #1 nation hit herself. The CMAs are low hanging fruit.”

Beyoncé’s hit, “Texas Maintain ‘Em,” was sitting at for 2 straight weeks, remaining on TheShockNews for 20 weeks.

A number of different songs off “Cowboy Carter” additionally landed on the chart, together with “16 Carriages,” “Jolene,” “Levii’s Denims,” “Blackbird,” “Ya Ya” and “Tyrant,” amongst others.

She was additionally the primary Black lady with the primary single on the Scorching Nation Songs chart, which she acknowledged in an , saying she felt “honored.”

One fan pointed to the album’s historical past on the charts and , “Nobody within the historical past of getting a #1 album AND music has been fully snubbed at an award present. IN ANY CATEGORY.”

“Beyoncé deserved higher,” the consumer added.

“Beyoncé nonetheless dominating the dialog across the CMAs regardless of them making an attempt to exclude her,” one other , including a video of TV host Wendy Williams punching the display.

Shaboozey, whose hit “Bar Tune (Tipsy)” took over the charts earlier this summer season, paid his personal tribute to Beyoncé. He ,” showing on the observe “Spaghettii.”

“That goes with out saying. Thanks @Beyonce for opening a door for us, beginning a dialog, and giving us some of the progressive nation albums of all time!” Shaboozey wrote on .

It’s price noting the CMAs are considered part of the “Cowboy Carter’s” foundational mythology – which is why some by the snub. “The complete Cowboy Carter is a diss-track to the CMAs,” one wrote.

When saying the album, Beyoncé cited an expertise during which she “didn’t really feel welcomed” because the inspiration for “Cowboy Carter.”

“This album has been over 5 years within the making. It was born out of an expertise that I had years in the past the place I didn’t really feel welcomed…and it was very clear that I wasn’t,” she wrote in

“The criticisms I confronted after I first entered this style pressured me to propel previous the constraints that had been placed on me,” she added. “Act ii is a results of difficult myself, and taking my time to bend and mix genres collectively to create this physique of labor.”

Followers thought she might need been of her music “Daddy Classes” with the Chicks.

Her first, and solely, time performing on the CMAs was met with backlash and booing.

Tanner Davenport, co-director of nation outlet Black Opry, that got here out in 2024 timed to “Cowboy Carter.”

Controversy grew when the CMAs didn’t publish the efficiency on their platforms and deleted the promotional publish it had shared, Elle’s 2016 screenshots confirmed that The Chicks and Beyoncé had been .

The CMAs mentioned in a remark to in 2016 {that a} promotional clip was deleted earlier than the efficiency at Beyoncé’s request.

Earlier than “Cowboy Carter” dropped, , “This ain’t a Nation album. It is a ‘Beyoncé’ album.”

This text was initially revealed on